Verified
For Matthew, the confirmation came when Michael answered a question he asked. The young man told him that he grew up in Poe Place. It was the same site as the incident Matthew had in mind. It blew their minds that they met again decades later! Matthew relayed the whole story to the younger man.

Verified
Call from Dispatch
Matthew Bailly could recall Poe Place as if it happened just yesterday. The incident took place in the small dead-end road people did not know about. He was new to the force at the time. As he was roving the streets, he got a call. He was still a rookie with only 4 years under his belt when he was told to go to Poe Place.

Call from Dispatch